FOR ONE NIGHT — PART III: “What If He Isn’t Who I Want Him to Be?”
It started with the note.
Not the one on the breakfast tray.
The next one.
The one tucked inside the matchbook from the Jazz Bar in Naples.
She hadn’t noticed it at first. But when it fell out into her hand three days later, the handwriting was unmistakable.
“You shouldn’t look for me. But I hope you do.”
That’s when the fantasies started.
At first, they were romantic.
She imagined him as a composer who had fled fame and fortune after a tragic accident — a man who could no longer bear applause, only silence and strangers.
Or a war correspondent, hardened and haunted, who’d spent too long in places no one ever really comes back from.
Or a man married once, maybe even still married, to a woman in a coma somewhere in a forgotten hospital room. A man bound by loyalty, and slowly breaking free for one night, just one.
But then, slowly, the fantasies turned.
What if the sadness in his eyes wasn’t melancholy, but guilt?
What if the elegance was practiced? The piano just part of a performance?
“What if he’s dangerous?”
The question hit her in Berlin, in a museum café, where she’d found another envelope — no name, no message, just a sketch of a grand piano and the numbers: 12.9.3.
She stared at it for hours. Then, her brain began stitching together the worst of her imagination.
Fantasy 1: The Killer Pianist
He travels from city to city, always staying for one night, always in hotel suites with grand pianos.
He seduces women, learns their secrets, and turns them into songs — and then? He erases them.
He never kills the same way twice. But the pattern is always there.
Maybe Claire’s the only one who saw through it.
Maybe he’s testing her.
Fantasy 2: The Collector
Not a killer. Not violent.
Just… obsessed.
He finds women on the edge of their lives, women about to break or bloom. He gives them magic for one night, then vanishes.
He keeps pieces of them — photos, lipstick-stained napkins, broken bracelets — in a hidden room somewhere.
Maybe he’s building a museum of moments.
And Claire is Exhibit 12.9.3.
Fantasy 3: The Ghost
Not metaphorical. Not poetic.
A real ghost.
Dead twenty years. Only appears in Suite 9C.
The music wasn’t unfinished — it was never meant to be heard again.
She wasn’t supposed to see him. But she did. And now… she can’t stop.
Sometimes, the fantasies thrilled her.
Other times, they left her shaking, clutching the necklace her grandmother gave her as if it were armor.
She began locking hotel doors twice.
Walking faster in crowded streets.
Searching faces in cafés and windows and train reflections.
And still — she followed the notes.
The sketches.
The songs.
Because what if he was none of those things?
What if he was just a man?
One who’d seen her in a way no one else had?
And what if she let fear turn that into something ugly?
She didn’t know what scared her more:
That he might be a monster…
Or that he might be real.
And she might already be in love with him.
To Be Continued…
Perhaps in Vienna. Or Prague. Or back in the suite where it all began…